# Productive Failure (Workshop) > A ready-to-run PD workshop on designing productive failure: struggle before instruction. Run-of-show, handout, follow-up. *A ready-to-run professional learning workshop from K12 Academics. Source page: https://pd.k12academics.com/productive-failure-workshop.html* It sounds backward, but letting students struggle with and even fail at a challenging problem before you teach them how to solve it can lead to deeper learning than teaching them first. This designed productive failure primes the mind for the instruction that follows. Letting students struggle with and even fail at a challenging problem before teaching the solution can deepen learning more than teaching first; designed productive failure primes the mind for the instruction that follows. ## Why it works Productive failure (a designed approach from Manu Kapur's research) reverses the usual order: instead of teaching a concept or method first and then having students practice, students first attempt to solve a novel, challenging problem on their own, generating and exploring their own approaches, often without fully succeeding, before the teacher provides instruction. Research shows this can lead to deeper conceptual understanding and transfer than instruction-first, because the struggle activates prior knowledge, reveals the limits of students' current thinking, highlights what matters, and prepares them to learn deeply from the subsequent instruction (they now understand why the taught method works and the problem it solves). The key is that it is designed, a carefully chosen problem, genuine student exploration, and then clear, consolidating instruction that connects to what students attempted. Failure here is productive precisely because it precedes and primes real learning. **The research:** Research on productive failure (Kapur). ## The run-of-show ### Staff meeting (15 minutes) A fast introduction to plant one routine. **Goal:** everyone leaves with one thing to try. | Start | Length | Segment | What happens | Facilitator note | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | 0:00 | 3 min | Hook | What if students struggled with a problem before you taught it? Why might it help? | You are surfacing a counterintuitive design. | | 0:03 | 5 min | Mini-teach | Struggle first, then teach. One slide. | | | 0:08 | 5 min | Plan one | Name a problem students could explore before instruction. Turn and talk. | | | 0:13 | 2 min | Commit | Each person names a lesson to redesign. | | ### PLC / team meeting (45 minutes) The standard version. **Goal:** every teacher leaves with something designed for a real upcoming lesson. | Start | Length | Segment | What happens | Facilitator note | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | 0:00 | 5 min | Hook | Teach-then-practice vs struggle-then-teach. Which deepens understanding? | Let them see the design. | | 0:05 | 8 min | Mini-teach | Productive failure and consolidating instruction. | | | 0:13 | 12 min | See it in action | Design exploration then consolidation. | Connect to attempts. | | 0:25 | 12 min | Design | Design productive failure. | Protect the full time. | | 0:37 | 5 min | Share | Swap designs in pairs; check the consolidation. | Keep it in pairs. | | 0:42 | 3 min | Commit + follow-up | Lock it in and set the check-in date. | | ### Half-day institute (~3 hours) A deep session for a PD day. **Goal:** built, practiced, and a rollout planned. | Start | Length | Segment | What happens | Facilitator note | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Block 1 | 45 min | Experience + why | Teach-first habit, then the research. | | | | 15 min | Break | | | | Block 2 | 60 min | Design lessons | Teams design productive-failure lessons. | Consolidating instruction. | | Block 3 | 45 min | Practice | Build a struggle-then-teach sequence. | Deeper learning is the aim. | | Close | 15 min | Plan the rollout | Try productive failure; set the check-in. | | ## The core activity: design productive failure Teachers leave with a struggle-first, then-consolidate lesson design. - Choose a challenging, novel problem students cannot yet fully solve. - Have them genuinely explore and attempt it first (generating approaches, often not fully succeeding). - Frame the struggle as productive, not failure to be graded. - Then provide clear instruction that consolidates and connects to what they tried. ## Facilitator notes - Choose a challenging novel problem, and have students explore first. - Frame struggle as productive. - Follow with consolidating instruction. ## Adapt it - **Elementary:** explore a problem first, then teach. - **Secondary:** novel problem, exploration, consolidating instruction. - **All settings:** struggle first by design, then consolidating instruction. ## Participant handout One page for every teacher. Print it, or save it as a PDF. ### Productive Failure: struggle, then consolidate **By design:** a challenging problem explored first, framed as productive, then clear consolidating instruction. - The challenging, novel problem students explore first: __________ - How students genuinely explore and attempt it: __________ - How I frame the struggle as productive: __________ - The clear instruction that consolidates and connects to their attempts: __________ - A lesson to redesign as productive failure: __________ ## Make it stick Struggle, then consolidate: - Design productive failure. - Consolidate afterward. - Bring a productive-failure lesson to the next PLC. ## Common questions **Why would I let students fail before teaching them?** Because designed productive failure, attempting a challenging problem before instruction, can deepen understanding and transfer: the struggle activates prior knowledge, reveals the limits of their thinking, and primes them to learn deeply from the instruction that follows. **Isn't failure discouraging?** Not when it is framed and designed as productive exploration before instruction, not a graded test. Students generate approaches, then learn why the taught method works. The struggle is the point, and instruction follows. **How do I design it?** Choose a challenging, novel problem; have students genuinely explore and attempt it (often without full success); then provide clear, consolidating instruction that connects to what they tried. Design, exploration, then instruction. ## Go deeper - [The Learning Scientists](https://www.learningscientists.org) ## Build it into a bigger day - [Productive Struggle](https://pd.k12academics.com/productive-struggle-workshop.html) - [Inquiry-Based Learning](https://pd.k12academics.com/inquiry-based-learning-workshop.html) - [The Pretesting Effect](https://pd.k12academics.com/pretesting-effect-workshop.html) --- Full workshop page: https://pd.k12academics.com/productive-failure-workshop.html All workshops: https://pd.k12academics.com/