# Separating Feedback From Grades (Workshop) > A ready-to-run PD workshop on separating feedback from grades so feedback actually lands. Run-of-show, handout, follow-up. *A ready-to-run professional learning workshop from K12 Academics. Source page: https://pd.k12academics.com/separating-feedback-grades-workshop.html* Here is a counterintuitive finding: when you put a grade and a comment on the same work, students read the grade and ignore the comment. Separating feedback from grades, at least sometimes, is what lets your careful feedback actually land. Research finds that when a grade and a comment appear together, students read the grade and ignore the comment; separating feedback from grades, at least sometimes, is what lets careful feedback actually land. ## Why it works Research (notably Ruth Butler) found that students given both a grade and a comment tend to focus on the grade and ignore the comment, gaining little, while students given comments alone engage with and benefit from the feedback. Grades, especially, crowd out the processing of feedback and can shift students toward ego and performance rather than learning. Strategies to separate feedback from grades, giving comment-only feedback at times, returning feedback before the grade, requiring students to act on feedback before seeing a grade, help feedback actually land and keep the focus on learning. **The research:** Research on grades and feedback (Butler). ## The run-of-show ### Staff meeting (15 minutes) A fast introduction to plant one routine. **Goal:** everyone leaves with one thing to try. | Start | Length | Segment | What happens | Facilitator note | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | 0:00 | 3 min | Hook | When you return graded work, do students read your comments? Name it. | You are surfacing ignored feedback. | | 0:03 | 5 min | Mini-teach | Grades crowd out feedback, so separate them. One slide. | | | 0:08 | 5 min | Plan one | Name a way to separate feedback from the grade. Turn and talk. | | | 0:13 | 2 min | Commit | Each person names a task to try it on. | | ### PLC / team meeting (45 minutes) The standard version. **Goal:** every teacher leaves with something designed for a real upcoming lesson. | Start | Length | Segment | What happens | Facilitator note | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | 0:00 | 5 min | Hook | Grade plus comment vs comment alone. Which gets read? | Let them see the research. | | 0:05 | 8 min | Mini-teach | Butler's finding and separation strategies. | | | 0:13 | 12 min | See it in action | Plan comment-only or feedback-first on a task. | Require engagement. | | 0:25 | 12 min | Design | Separate feedback from grades. | Protect the full time. | | 0:37 | 5 min | Share | Swap plans in pairs; add an engagement step. | Keep it in pairs. | | 0:42 | 3 min | Commit + follow-up | Lock it in and set the check-in date. | | ### Half-day institute (~3 hours) A deep session for a PD day. **Goal:** built, practiced, and a rollout planned. | Start | Length | Segment | What happens | Facilitator note | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Block 1 | 45 min | Experience + why | Ignored comments, then Butler's research. | | | | 15 min | Break | | | | Block 2 | 60 min | Plan separation | Teams plan comment-only and feedback-first tasks. | Group by subject. | | Block 3 | 45 min | Practice | Design a feedback-before-grade routine. | Letting feedback land is the aim. | | Close | 15 min | Plan the rollout | Adopt feedback-grade separation; set the check-in. | | ## The core activity: let feedback land by separating it Teachers leave with a way to separate feedback from grades on a task. - Notice whether students engage with your feedback or just check the grade. - Try separating them (comment-only at times, feedback before the grade, or acting on feedback before the grade appears). - Require students to engage with the feedback. - Keep the focus on learning, not the score. ## Facilitator notes - Give comment-only feedback at times, or feedback before the grade. - Require engagement with feedback first. - Keep focus on learning. ## Adapt it - **Elementary:** comment-only, act on feedback first. - **Secondary:** comment-only at times, feedback before grade. - **All settings:** separate feedback from grades, require engagement. ## Participant handout One page for every teacher. Print it, or save it as a PDF. ### Separating Feedback From Grades: let it land **Grades crowd out comments:** give feedback without the grade, at least sometimes, and require engagement with it. - Whether students engage with my feedback or just check the grade: __________ - How I will separate feedback from grades (comment-only, feedback first): __________ - How I require students to engage with feedback: __________ - How I keep the focus on learning: __________ - A task to try it on: __________ ## Make it stick - Separate feedback from grades. - Require engagement. - Bring a separated-feedback result to the next PLC. ## Common questions **Why do students ignore my comments?** Research finds that when a grade accompanies a comment, students focus on the grade and ignore the comment. Separating them, comment-only or feedback-before-grade, lets the feedback land. **Do I have to stop grading?** No. But at times, give comment-only feedback, return feedback before the grade, or have students act on feedback before seeing the grade, so the feedback is processed, not crowded out. **Won't students just want the grade?** Often yes, which is the problem. Separating feedback from grades (at least sometimes) and requiring engagement with feedback first keeps the focus on learning, not just the score. ## Go deeper - [The Learning Scientists](https://www.learningscientists.org) ## Build it into a bigger day - [Feedback That Moves Learning](https://pd.k12academics.com/feedback-that-moves-learning-workshop.html) - [Feedback Literacy](https://pd.k12academics.com/feedback-literacy-students-workshop.html) - [Grading for Equity](https://pd.k12academics.com/grading-for-equity-workshop.html) --- Full workshop page: https://pd.k12academics.com/separating-feedback-grades-workshop.html All workshops: https://pd.k12academics.com/