Professional Learning  ›  EdTech & AI  ›  Workshops  ›  Rethinking Assessment in an AI World
a ready-to-run workshopRethinking Assessment in an AI World
EdTech & AI · Workshop

Rethinking Assessment in an AI World (Workshop)

When AI can write a passable essay or solve a problem set in seconds, some traditional assignments no longer tell us what a student actually knows. Rethinking assessment for an AI world means designing tasks that still reveal genuine learning, whether by making the thinking visible, or by using AI openly.

Key takeaway

AI can complete many traditional assignments, so some no longer reveal genuine learning; rethinking assessment means designing tasks that still show real understanding, by making thinking visible or using AI openly.

Format
PLC / team meeting
Length
45 minutes
Group size
Any (works 4-40)
Who can run it
Any teacher-leader
You will need
Slides (5)Printed handoutAn AI-vulnerable assessmentA timer
Aligned to
Learning Forward: Rigorous ContentInTASC 6: AssessmentEmerging practice on AI and assessment
Share / assign

Why it works

Generative AI can produce competent responses to many traditional take-home assignments, which means some of them no longer reliably reveal what a student knows. Rather than only policing this, emerging practice suggests rethinking assessment: designing tasks that make student thinking and process visible (in-class work, drafts, discussion, explanation, application to novel or personal contexts), or deliberately incorporating AI with the assessment focused on the student's critique, judgment, and reasoning. The goal is assessment that still measures genuine learning in a world where AI exists.

The research: Emerging practice on assessment and generative AI.

The run-of-show

Choose your slot. The agenda, timings, and length update to match.

    The core activity: redesign an assessment for an AI world

    Teachers leave with one assessment redesigned to reveal genuine thinking.

    Assess the thinking AI can't fakeAI can complete many traditional tasks. Design assessment that reveals genuine thinking, process, judgment, understanding, in or out of class.

    Facilitator notes

    Some traditional assignments no longer reveal learningIf AI can produce the assignment, it may not show what the student knows. Redesign to reveal genuine thinking, or build AI in with the focus on judgment.

    Adapt it

    Participant handout

    One page for every teacher. Print it, or save it as a PDF.

    K12 Academics · Professional Learning

    Assessment in an AI World: assess the thinking

    Reveal real learning: make process visible, use novel contexts, or build AI in focused on judgment.

    1. The assessment AI could now complete:
    2. How I redesign it to reveal thinking:
    3. The process or context that makes it genuine:
    4. How I might build AI in focused on judgment:
    5. How I ensure it measures real understanding:

    Make it stick

    Assess genuine thinking:

    Common questions

    Does AI mean I can never assign take-home writing again?
    Not necessarily, but recognize that AI can complete many such tasks. Make thinking and process visible (drafts, in-class, explanation), use novel or personal contexts, or build AI into the task with the focus on the student's judgment.
    Should I just go back to in-class, handwritten everything?
    That is one option for some assessments, but not the only one. The broader move is designing tasks that reveal genuine thinking and understanding, which AI cannot fake, in or out of class.
    Can I use AI in assessment productively?
    Yes, design tasks where students use AI openly and are assessed on their critique, revision, judgment, and reasoning, not on the AI output. Assess the thinking.

    Go deeper

    Build it into a bigger day