Why it works
Even with a shared rubric, teachers often score the same work differently, which makes grades unfair and common assessments uninterpretable. Calibration (or moderation), scoring sample student work together, comparing scores, and discussing until the team agrees on how the rubric applies, builds inter-rater consistency and, just as valuably, a shared, sharpened understanding of what quality looks like. Research on assessment reliability supports it as essential for fair, comparable grading.
The research: Research on scoring reliability and moderation.
The run-of-show
Choose your slot. The agenda, timings, and length update to match.
The core activity: calibrate scoring as a team
Teams leave scoring consistently, with anchor papers for each level.
- Take a rubric and sample student work.
- Have everyone score the same samples independently.
- Compare scores and discuss the differences.
- Agree on how the rubric applies and anchor with example papers at each level.
Facilitator notes
- Score samples independently, then compare.
- Discuss and resolve differences, anchoring with exemplars.
- Calibrate periodically.
Adapt it
- Elementary and secondary: the same process.
- Teams: bring common work.
- All settings: independent scoring, discussion, agreement.
Participant handout
One page for every teacher. Print it, or save it as a PDF.
Calibration: score the same
Fair, comparable grades: score samples independently, resolve differences, and anchor each level with exemplars.
- The rubric and sample work:
- The independent scores and where they differed:
- How we resolved the differences:
- The anchor papers for each level:
- How often we will calibrate:
Make it stick
Consistent scoring:
- Calibrate scoring.
- Anchor with exemplars.
- Bring calibrated scoring to common assessments.